Emerson T. Brooking

THINKER, TINKER · DEFENSE, AI, THE INTERNET · WASHINGTON, DC

Multicolored bars crossing a blue circle; adapted from the Canadian Commercial Corporation annual report, 1979–80

Work

ANALYSISInternational Cyberspace & Digital Policy Strategy Markup

MAY 2024

The State Department’s first cyberspace strategy states the US position clearly against the Chinese and Russian models, but it remains more a statement of purpose than a record of results. Annotated line by line by Atlantic Council technology experts.

WITH SAFA SHAHWAN EDWARDS, ROSE JACKSON, KONSTANTINOS KOMAITIS ET AL.

ATLANTIC COUNCIL (external)
ANALYSISGaza and the Future of Information Warfare

DEC 2023

The stronger side in a modern war uses conventional power to take the weaker one offline, as Israel did in Gaza by bombing cell towers and winning platform compliance with 94 percent of its takedown requests. Chinese military researchers are studying the same playbook.

WITH P.W. SINGER

FOREIGN AFFAIRS (external)
ANALYSISWelcome to Cyber Realism

SEP 2023

The 2023 DoD Cyber Strategy, argue its own drafters, quietly drops decades of “cyber Pearl Harbor” alarmism for modest aims: the Pentagon can’t defend every network, and cyber works only alongside other tools of power.

WITH ERICA LONERGAN

WAR ON THE ROCKS (external)
ANALYSISDraft Trump Executive Order Shows How False Foreign Interference Claims May Be Used to Undermine U.S. Elections

APR 2022

A December 2020 draft executive order would have had the Pentagon seize voting machines nationwide, on the fabricated ground that Dominion Voting Systems was foreign-controlled. Allegations of foreign interference make a better pretext than domestic fraud because they cannot readily be checked.

JUST SECURITY (external)
ANALYSISMeta Meets the Reality of War

MAR 2022

Meta’s leaked guidance briefly allowed Ukrainians to call for violence against invading Russian soldiers. A garbled Reuters headline turned it into a pretext for Russia to ban Instagram. No content policy can be precise enough for a war.

TECH POLICY PRESS (external)
ANALYSISHow to End Israel’s Digital Occupation

DEC 2021

Palestinian speech online is suppressed by a mix of Israeli arrests, platform pressure campaigns, and an expansive definition of antisemitism. The remedy proposed is for social media companies to treat the State of Palestine, recognized by 138 countries, as they treat other states.

WITH ELIZA ASPEN

FOREIGN POLICY (external)
ANALYSISWhat We Learned in the DNI's New Election Report

MAR 2021

The declassified intelligence assessment of 2020 election interference shows the threat evolving: Russia dropped the WikiLeaks-style cutouts and pitched influence directly to Trump allies, Iran grew more aggressive, and China judged meddling not worth the risk.

DEFENSE ONE (external)
ANALYSISAmericans Were Worried About the Wrong Threat

JAN 2021

The collapse of a shared American political reality, not foreign trolls, is the country’s gravest information threat, and years of domestic disinformation built the “tinderbox of rage and delusion” that produced January 6. Addressing it without overcorrection will be harder, and the United States has a poor record there.

WITH JACOB SHAPIRO

THE ATLANTIC (external)
ANALYSISOp-Ed: For right-wing extremists, this was a victory

JAN 2021

The Capitol attack was a victory for the far right, and its images will recruit for a generation. What January 6 produced is a post-Trump extremist movement, more likely than its predecessors to undertake acts of violence.

DFRLAB (external)
ANALYSISForeign Influence Operations After 2020

OCT 2020

The debate over foreign influence operations has hardened into two camps, one warning of an information conflict between democracies and autocracies, the other of a “disinformation industrial complex.” What the field needs is better research standards, less hyperbole, and attention to elections beyond the United States.

LAWFARE (external)
ANALYSISCoverage of Hunter Biden story illustrates extremes in media polarization

OCT 2020

Coverage of the unverified Hunter Biden laptop story reached a partisan audience almost exclusively: 85 percent of the 33 million shares the top stories drew in five days went to adamantly pro-Trump websites. That lopsidedness exceeds even the antifa coverage of June 2020.

DFRLAB (external)
ANALYSISThe Senate Created a Playbook to Counter Foreign Influence. Then It Did the Opposite.

AUG 2020

The Senate Intelligence Committee’s four-volume report laid out bipartisan recommendations for resisting foreign interference, while a separate Senate probe led by Ron Johnson gave Kremlin-linked operatives a channel for laundering disinformation about Joe Biden. Congress itself has become a vector of attack.

WITH GRAHAM BROOKIE

JUST SECURITY (external)
ANALYSISThe Russians Are Meddling in the Democratic Primary. Is Anyone Paying Attention?

OCT 2019

A new Russian influence operation reached roughly 147,000 US Instagram users and concentrated on the swing state of Florida, running the 2016 playbook of infiltrating both sides of contentious political debates.

WASHINGTON POST (external)
ANALYSISThe Christchurch Call and the Failure of US Leadership

MAY 2019

The United States refused to sign the 2019 Christchurch Call against online extremism, abandoning commitments it had made against ISIS content two years earlier. The only apparent difference is that the terrorists in question are now white ethno-nationalists.

ATLANTIC COUNCIL (external)
ANALYSISWhite Nationalism Overshadowed at Congressional Hearing on White Nationalism

APR 2019

Twitter mentions of Candace Owens outpaced mentions of white nationalism after she sparred with Rep. Ted Lieu at an April 2019 hearing on hate crimes, drowning out Google and Facebook testimony on content moderation.

WITH MELISSA HALL

DFRLAB (external)
ANALYSISThe Very First Social Network

OCT 2018

In 1979, a chain email asking ARPANET researchers their favorite science fiction authors became, in Vint Cerf’s words, proof ‘we had a social medium on our hands’ — the direct ancestor of the internet we know today.

WITH P.W. SINGER

SLATE (external)
ANALYSISHow October 7th, 2016 Shaped the Course of American History

OCT 2018

October 7th, 2016 was the day that Hillary Clinton appeared to win the presidential election. She was ahead in the polls in every contested state, with twice the field offices as Donald Trump and twice the cash on hand. She had been blanketing the airwaves with ads and was on her way to being endorsed by 95 percent of all newspaper editorial boards. And then, at 4:05 P.M. EST, the Access Hollywood tape dropped.

ROLLING STONE (external)
FULL TEXT
ANALYSISWhat Clausewitz Can Teach Us About War on Social Media

OCT 2018

Clausewitz’s center of gravity, a people’s spirit and will, explains why social media succeeds at wartime persuasion where WWII radio and Vietnam-era leaflets failed. Adapted from LikeWar.

WITH P.W. SINGER

FOREIGN AFFAIRS (external)
ANALYSISWhy Americans Aren’t Paying Attention to the Longest War in Their Nation’s History

OCT 2018

Americans have stopped paying attention to the longest war in their history. A Taliban assault on a strategic city 75 miles from Kabul drew almost no notice, and the conflict’s one viral moment was mockery of the MOAB’s nickname.

WITH P.W. SINGER

TIME (external)
ANALYSISSocial Media Is Revolutionizing Warfare

OCT 2018

Michael Flynn grasped early that open-source data had overtaken secrets as the raw material of intelligence. The same online battlefield later helped bring him down. Excerpted from LikeWar.

WITH P.W. SINGER

THE ATLANTIC (external)
ANALYSISHow the Kavanaugh Information War Mirrors Real Warzones

OCT 2018

The Kavanaugh fight ran on information-war tactics: crowdsourced OSINT into his finances, a doppelganger theory echoing Russia’s MH17 disinformation, and a Wikipedia entry rewritten during his testimony. Such tactics will become the norm.

WITH P.W. SINGER

WIRED (external)
ANALYSISImmigration Fight Shows Silicon Valley Must Stop Feigning Neutrality

JUL 2018

Twitter banned a crowdsourced database of ICE agents, built from public LinkedIn profiles, as “doxing,” then suspended accounts that shared Stephen Miller’s phone number. The platforms already make political choices and should stop pretending otherwise.

WITH P.W. SINGER

WIRED (external)
ANALYSISWhen Should the 9/11 War End?

SEP 2015

A law written for nineteen 9/11 hijackers now underwrites counterterrorism operations in a quarter of the world’s nations. It needs an open congressional debate and a rewrite, not indefinite renewal.

THE NATIONAL INTEREST (external)
ANALYSISWorld War I’s ‘D-Day’ Disaster: The Gallipoli Tragedy

APR 2015

Gallipoli was doomed before the landings began, by Churchill’s unearned faith in naval bombardment and a commander whose only contingency plan assumed success. Eight months of fighting gained four miles of ground.

THE NATIONAL INTEREST (external)
ANALYSISThe U.S. Government Should Pay Anonymous in Bitcoin to Fight ISIS

MAR 2015

A nonprofit foundation sponsored by the anti-Islamic State coalition should pay hacktivists bounties in Bitcoin for identifying and disabling the group’s accounts, recruiting sites, and VPN channels. Washington has armed irregular partners before.

FOREIGN POLICY (external)
ANALYSISA Century Ago Today, the Age of Industrial Warfare Began

JAN 2015

On August 7, 1914, the French advanced into German-controlled Alscace, beating back the German divisions with a vicious display of massed firepower and artillery. This was the opening day of the Battle of the Frontiers, a month-long struggle of maneuver in which French, British, and German armies played tug-of-war across a 440-mile front. This was World War I before the trenches, where the visions of nineteenth-century military planners collided with the realities of twentieth-century industrial warfare. The battle saw 670,000 dead or wounded in a month---the highest density of losses in the entire war. This month would shatter a century of military doctrine.

FULL TEXT
ANALYSISMore Than 6,000 Afghan Interpreters Are Stuck in Bureaucratic Limbo

OCT 2014

The Afghan visa program for interpreters who served alongside US forces awarded 32 visas in 2012 against more than 5,700 applicants. It was due to lapse at the end of 2014, with two extension bills stalled in Congress.

WITH JANINE DAVIDSON

DEFENSE ONE (external)
ANALYSISThe ISIS Propaganda Machine Is Horrifying and Effective. How Does It Work?

AUG 2014

The Islamic State's "A Message to America," showing American journalist James Foley's final moments, is vile and horrifying. Significantly, unlike the early propaganda of Al Qaeda, this video is also professionally cut and edited. It is the sort of thing engineered to achieve rapid, viral spread on the open internet. It also represents the main weapon the Islamic State is increasingly employing to great effect against the West.

FULL TEXT
ANALYSISIn Iraq, What Exactly Was the Alternative?

JUN 2014

"We Never Should Have Left Iraq." "Who Lost Iraq?" "Bush warned this would happen in Iraq." "Obama's Iraq disaster." "The Collapsing Obama Doctrine." "Sometimes withdrawal is the stupidest thing of all."

FULL TEXT
ANALYSISWhat Now for America’s Young, Jobless Soldiers?

NOV 2013

Post-9/11 veterans aged 18 to 24 face unemployment above 20 percent. The Pentagon’s deepest personnel cuts in decades will send many more of them into that market as federal hiring and the GI Bill erode.

THE NATIONAL INTEREST (external)
ANALYSISNeverwinter Nevermore

JAN 2010

Neverwinter Nights occupies a strange corner of PC gaming history. It was the last of the great Dungeons & Dragons RPG epics (following Planescape: Torment, Icewind Dale, and Baldur's Gate) and the first to be rendered in 3D. It was also the last "old-school" BioWare game, coming as the studio was already shifting gears toward Knights of the Old Republic. While Neverwinter Nights saw strong reviews and enough commercial success to spawn two expansion packs and an Obsidian-produced sequel, it was a flawed masterpiece. Its graphics were outdated almost immediately; its single-player campaign was unremarkable.

THE ESCAPIST (external)
FULL TEXT